Liam Hemsworth and henry cavill as the witcher

Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher: Right Choice or Wrong Move by Netflix?

News & Updates / Leave a Comment

The Witcher Season 4 Trailer Finally Reveals Liam Hemsworth as Geralt

Netflix dropped the official trailer for The Witcher Season 4 on October 7, and one thing fans’ reaction has centered on is Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher.

This is the first time we saw Henry Cavill’s iconic Geralt in someone else’s form. The trailer opens with a darker, war-torn Continent where chaos is everywhere, and Ciri’s powers have become a magnet for danger.

Liam Hemsworth‘s entry shot white hair, dual swords, and that familiar gravelly tone instantly reminds us of Cavill’s version. But at the same time, there’s something different, something new that this season has brought.

Henry Cavill’s Legacy: A Tough Act to Follow

Let’s be honest, Henry Cavill gave The Witcher a cult status. From his deep understanding of Sapkowski’s books to his physicality and stoic performance, Cavill was Geralt of Rivia for millions of fans.

So naturally, when Netflix announced that Cavill would be exiting after Season 3 and Liam Hemsworth would be taking over the role, fans were pretty divided.

Now the Season 4 trailer has ignited this discussion again: Can Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher really fill those shoes?

First Impressions: Liam Hemsworth’s Geralt Feels Familiar Yet Fresh

The visuals in the trailer clearly show that Netflix has kept Liam close to Henry’s style, the voice modulation, the stance, even the calm-before-the-storm look.

But if you look carefully, Liam’s Geralt appears a bit more expressive. He seems younger, more emotionally open, especially in scenes with Yennefer and Ciri.

There’s a moment in the middle of the trailer where Geralt stands in the middle of a burning battlefield. It’s cinematic, powerful, and Liam’s presence feels surprisingly solid.

So perhaps Netflix’s plan was not to make this a carbon copy of Cavill’s Geralt, but a new evolution of the character.

The Story Setup: A Darker Continent Awaits

Season 4 trailer makes it clear The Witcher is entering its darkest phase.

Ciri is now a fugitive, her powers growing uncontrollably. Yennefer’s arc seems deeply tied to dark magic once again. And the most interesting entry is Laurence Fishburne as Regis, a vampire straight from Sapkowski’s novels.

There are a few shots in the trailer that seem to be directly inspired by the Baptism of Fire and Tower of the Swallow novels, meaning Season 4 will lean heavily into the Witcher Saga’s later storylines.

It is against this backdrop that Liam Hemsworth’s Geralt looks like a soldier, tired yet determined, ready to face both war and destiny.

Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher

Why Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher Might Actually Work

Many were initially skeptical about how Liam Hemsworth would handle such a serious role, especially after light-hearted films like The Hunger Games and Isn’t It Romantic.

But here are some solid reasons why this casting might actually click:

1. Fresh Energy:

Cavill’s Geralt seemed like a veteran monster slayer, but Liam’s version feels like a rejuvenated warrior. This tonal shift fits with Ciri’s growth arc.

2. Book Accuracy:

In Andrzej Sapkowski’s novels, Geralt often shows more humor and emotional vulnerability. Liam’s trailer performance seems to be headed in the same direction.

3. Chemistry with Ciri and Yennefer:

The trailer features a few blink-and-miss moments where Liam’s Geralt and Anya Chalotra’s Yennefer share an emotional exchange, and honestly, it works.

4. New Visual Tone:

Season 4’s lighting and cinematography feel more raw and gritty, matching Liam’s less polished, more human portrayal.

This recasting by Netflix is ​​certainly a creative risk, but if audiences watch with an open mind, Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher may surprise a lot of people.

The Concerns Fans Still Have

Of course, not all fans were convinced.

Discussions on Reddit and Common fan concerns:
  • Voice depth: Liam’s voice is not gravelly to Cavill’s “Hmm” level.
  • Body language: Cavill’s Geralt looked like a calm storm; Liam seems a little more action-heavy.
  • Emotional weight: Fans wonder if Liam can capture that same inner pain that defined Cavill’s Geralt.

These concerns are genuine because The Witcher fans don’t just watch the action; they connect emotionally with Geralt’s philosophy and loneliness.

Henry Cavill vs Liam Hemsworth: A Fair Comparison?

Liam Hemsworth vs Henry cavill's witcher

Honestly, comparisons were bound to happen. After Henry Cavill elevated The Witcher to such a level, it was nearly impossible for any other actor to fill those shoes. Cavill’s Geralt was a silent storm – brooding, composed, and bringing a natural authority to every scene. His screen presence and seriousness made the character mythic.

On the other hand, Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher brings a very different energy. It’s clear from the trailer itself that Liam’s Geralt is slightly younger, faster, and emotionally expressive. Where Cavill’s Geralt seemed like an experienced monster slayer, Liam’s version feels like a warrior in progress – a little raw, a little vulnerable.

From the perspective of the books, Liam’s approach is actually closer to the tone of the original Geralt, where sarcasm and humor were also important parts. Cavill created a stoic hero, while Liam brings a bit of warmth and unpredictability to that same hero.

In short, the interpretations of both are different – Cavill brought gravitas, Liam brings freshness. And this contrast could give the show a new identity, if the writing of Season 4 justifies its potential.

The Witcher Season 4: Trailer Highlights Worth Noticing

Some sequences in the trailer stand out:

  • Ciri is training with a group of rogues (possibly The Rats).
  • Yennefer is exploring forbidden magic once again.
  • A massive war sequence showing the Northern Kingdoms in chaos.
  • Geralt is fighting what looks like a mutated monster in a fiery ruin, possibly a hint toward the Beauclair arc.

These glimpses confirm that this season will be more about inner battles than monster hunts, and Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher fits that new tone.

The Final Verdict: Right Choice or Wrong Move?

Look, Henry Cavill’s exit was an emotional wound for Witcher fans, no doubt.

But judging by this trailer, Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher doesn’t look like a disaster; in fact, he looks like a solid continuation.

Netflix has clearly shifted its vision a bit to a darker world, faster pacing, and emotionally richer character arcs.

If Liam maintained a balance between physical action and emotional subtlety, then this could become one of Netflix’s best redemption stories.

So maybe, just maybe, this is the right choice, provided Season 4 delivers on story and tone.

When and Where to Watch

The Witcher Season 4 premieres October 30, 2025, exclusively on Netflix.

It will serve as one of the final two seasons concluding the saga, leading directly into Season 5, the grand finale.

So get ready for another chaotic Continent journey, where destiny and danger walk together.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, The Witcher has always been a layered story, less about monsters and more about humanity.

Liam Hemsworth as The Witcher may not have Cavill’s legacy yet, but he clearly has the intent and respect for the role.

Fans will just have to give it some time because every new Geralt gets their own “Hmmm” moment.

Must Read

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *